Reading: from Climate, Class, and Claptrap, by Garret Keizer
I woke in the middle of the night, unable to sleep, probably due to some indigestible thing I’d eaten, a sacred cow or a digital polar bear. On my way back to bed from scribbling some of these words, I looked out the window and saw the stars through the bare branches of the century-old-and-older sugar maples that line my dirt road. I confess that iconic, God’s eye views of Earth do not move me, but starlight through the bare branches of maple trees in one radically particular place can move me a great deal. If the earth continues to grow warmer, I may live to see the day when sugar maples no longer exist at this latitude. I think of that line of Rilke’s, written after beholding another particular object of beauty, “You must change your life.”
But how? It is not enough to acknowledge that global warming exists; we also need to ask what global warming means. Surely one thing it means is that a culture that has as its highest aim the avoidance of anything remotely resembling physical work must change its life. If you want an inconvenient truth, there it is: that the very notion of convenience upon which our civilization rests is a lie that is killing us. And if you want to see how quickly green can turn yellow, make mention of that abundant, renewable fuel source whose chief emission is human sweat.
[He goes on to say...]
...You do not repair the climate on an entire planet without staggering sacrifices, and people will not elect to make staggering sacrifices unless the burden is shared with something like parity...The game of finding someone else in some convenient misery to fight our wars, pull our rickshaws, and serve as the offset for every filthy indulgence is just about up. It is either Earth for all of us or hell for most of us...
Homily: What Color Is Your Soul?
(what follows are the notes from which the homily was delivered)
Several concerns bouncing around in my head:
Our overly busy lives and the need to simplify
the stress and tiredness I see among our people
the clutter on my desk
global warming and catastrophic climate changes
the impending expiration of the lease on our car
the flea market three weeks from now
Thoreau’s experiment in simple living
Rumi’s ecstatic love
I have a feeling that they are all related
the article in this month’s Harpers Magazine
started to connect the dots
so I offer a reflection in three parts
Part I – Color Me Cluttered
ten days ago, taking advantage of a week free from preaching
started collecting things for the flea market
easy stuff first:
a shopping bag full of wire hangers
reminded me of the symbolism of coat hanger
Sydney and I used to challenge each other to create a homily on a given object
candle, dollar bill, key, brick, screwdriver
and then coat hanger, and I blanked
completely missed coat hangers as symbol of pain and desperation
clothes from forty pounds ago
a few books of the several dozen we buy every year, why could I only find eight to donate?
hoarding instinct – I’m not that good a buyer
dishes, glassware, kitchen gadgets, tools
remembering how my parents were able to outfit my first apartment
from things they had in storage
magazines – how they pile up, usually open to an unfinished article
I require of myself that I read at least one article before disposing of the issue
not for flea market
take them to Kaiser and leave them in waiting rooms
satisfaction –
I had crossed a couple of items off my to-do list
creating space
getting rid of jams
being able to find things easily
giving myself room to work
time to sit down and reflect on what all this stuff says about my life
invite you all to do the same
in fact, let’s take a few moments now to do that
Part II – Color Me Odd
that was all fairly easy and fun
then my desk
couldn’t even face it until I has built up some momentum
by handling other accumulations
layers of stuff overlain with layers of more recent stuff
all of some importance, none of it vital
a lot of it just waiting for me to figure out which file it goes into
or to create a file for it, since it’s a new category
I clear it away every six weeks or so
it stays clear for a few hours
only a few hours
clutter because I’m a P on Myers Briggs
comfortable with paradox
not driven to catagorize, sort, label, or judge
prefer process orientation
don’t have a psychological need for order or closure
but I may have a survival need for it
things get covered over and forgotten
lots of time spent trying to unearth papers I need
occasionally missed deadlines
mostly a matter of when and how I get satisfaction
the work involved in sorting and filing isn’t nearly as satisfying as reading Rumi
or gardening, or dare I say it, shopping
so things pile up
stuff gets piled on top of stuff
I can spend a whole hour on the internet trying to save ten dollars on medication for my dog’s arthritis
when that same hour would be worth far to me if I spent it making out reimbursement vouchers for professional expenses
and an hour spent sorting and filing would be worth at least that much in time saved trying to find things later
I could claim to be a child of my time
easily distracted (hyperlink syndrome)
acquisitive in behavior, if not in values
easily bored with rote tasks
of short attention span
craving entertainment feeding spiritual hunger by raiding the fridge or perusing catalogues
driven by anxiety and fear, the stock in trade of advertizing and politics
Some of that undoubtedly true
but I fit a strange demographic
advertisers don’t even bother with me (unless their selling electronics)
market test showed that I fall outside the norm
reading habits – other,
TV shows – other,
movies – other,
music – other,
food – other,
hobbies – other,
occupation – other,
vacations – other
also unusual level of education
unusual religion
OTHER in every category
color me ODD
let the congregation say AMEN
but like any good American I keep trying to solve the problem of my cluttering habit through technology
low tech, but tech none the less
surround myself with shelves, drawers, boxes, pigeon holes, baskets, cases, filing systems
so far none has managed to train me
and the piles keep growing
I always have my eye out for the gadget or the system that will tame my vagrant spirit
What do you get for the man who has everything? Something to keep it in...
So when I read Garret Keizer’s essay on global warming in this month’s Harpers
with its acerbic comments on our national affinity for comfort, convenience, and the technological fix,
I immediately thought, Whoa He’s talking about me!
And I sat down again to reflect on what I can do to slow the process of climate change
Part III – Color Me Troubled
I’ve already taken the three bulb pledge, replacing burned out incandescent lamps with fluorescents whenever feasible
have as yet seen on cost/benefit study on replacing good incandescent bulbs with fluorescents,
so I wait till a bulb dies
I’ve also discovered that some fluorescent bulbs don’t have a very long life
so I sometimes feel like I’ve been had
I recycle – paper, glass, cans, plastic, and old clothing and household goods
I drive fewer than 7000 miles a year and live only two miles from where I work
do most of my work in my home office
I live in a 1200 square foot home that’s easy to heat and cool
But I live in an all-electric house in a state that relies on fossil fuels for almost all of its energy
I still eat produce that comes from thousands of miles away
– love those green salads in January and apples in May –
Somehow I manage to fill a 50 gallon trash barrel each week
I use the dishwasher every other day,
the washer and dryer one day a week, usually at least two loads,
sometimes as many as four
and my car only averages 22 miles to a gallon of gasoline
but if I trade it in for one with better mileage, it will still be on the road,
so where’s the gain?
I know that if I’m to be a responsible citizen of the future,
and reduce my energy usage
(and other contributions to the green house effect)
I’ll have to change my life
But I can’t even make myself keep my desk clear
How do I make even bigger changes?
What do I know?
The beginning of lists
writing down the pieces
Glaciers are disappearing, I’ve seen it
ice caps are melting
trees are being cut faster than they are being planted
the bee population has been decimated
storms are wilder, more frequent, and more violent
mean temperatures in VA are rising and climate zones are changing
Robins arrived in January this year
more people spending more time in cars
I know from experience that if I am going to change habits, I can’t do it alone.
I need to have someone to go through this together with me, a coach, a buddy, a nag, someone to whom I will feel responsible,
and I need the cooperation of everyone who would be affected by any changes.
If someone close to me is trying to make changes,
I need to change my expectations in order to make room for that to happen
This awareness by itself might completely alter our national approach to diplomacy and international cooperation.
And the changes we make may well push us even further from the norm
because they may mean dropping out of the high energy society
By myself I can’t really make much of a difference. A single 18-wheeler uses more gasoline in a day than I do in a month; a jet fighter beats that ten fold or more,
but by working with others I can increase the effectiveness of my own contributions
Coalitions are even more effective
EPA standards are insufficient. Work for California standards or Japanese standards
The best motivator for changing our culture is government pressure on business and industry;
but customer demand can also change what business and industry are willing to do
Boycotting products that waste energy
- because of distance
- because of inefficient means of production
doesn’t help unless we state publically why we are avoiding them
suppliers’ first response otherwise is to look at taste or quality or freshness
Time may be money, it is also energy.
The faster you go, the farther you go, the more energy you use
the more CO2 you produce
If we don’t figure out how to change things
the changes will come anyway, but we won’t be able to control them.
The earth will maintain its balances and life will go on,
but it may go on without us
creating a new kind of painful desperation
I also know that I don’t have to make a difference,
I do have to make a contribution
somewhere in all this is the moon seen through the trees
moments of ecstatic clarity when we know
that we love this blue planet
and start to put its needs before our own
because we see that its needs are our own
when that happens, color us green
So I am announcing a theme
my theme for next year
simplicity
a surprisingly complex idea
think about it
and in the meantime, let’s sing about it